Can You Claim Self-Defense Against an Assault Charge in Michigan?
Can You Claim Self-Defense Against an Assault Charge in Michigan?
An argument or confrontation can escalate quickly, and sometimes the person who believed they were protecting themselves ends up facing an assault charge. If that happens, one of the first questions may be: Can I argue that I acted in self-defense?
Michigan law recognizes self-defense in appropriate circumstances. However, simply saying you were defending yourself does not automatically make an assault charge disappear. Whether self-defense applies depends on what happened, the amount of force used, who initiated the confrontation, and what you reasonably believed at the time.
What Is Self-Defense in Michigan?
Michigan law allows a person to use force to protect themselves or another person under certain circumstances.
For nondeadly force, Michigan's model criminal jury instructions provide that a person may use force when they honestly and reasonably believe it is necessary to protect themselves or another person from the imminent unlawful use of force.
This can become particularly important in an assault case where the accused maintains that their actions were a response to someone else's aggression rather than an unlawful attack.
What Does "Honestly and Reasonably Believe" Mean?
Self-defense involves more than simply claiming you felt threatened.
The circumstances must support an honest and reasonable belief that force was necessary to protect against imminent unlawful force. Michigan courts recognize that whether sufficient evidence supports a self-defense theory can ultimately be a question for the jury when the defense is properly raised.
That means the events immediately leading up to the confrontation can be extremely important.
Questions may include:
- Who initiated the confrontation?
- Was someone threatening or attempting to use force?
- How immediate was the threat?
- What did each person say or do?
- Were there witnesses?
- Was there surveillance or cellphone footage?
- What level of force was used in response?
The answers can help determine whether a self-defense argument may apply.
Does the Force Used Have to Be Reasonable?
The amount and type of force used matter.
If someone reasonably believes another person is about to unlawfully use nondeadly force, the legal analysis differs from a situation involving deadly force.
Michigan's jury instructions distinguish between deadly and nondeadly force. Deadly force generally requires an honest and reasonable belief that it is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm, or sexual assault. Nondeadly force may be justified when honestly and reasonably believed necessary to prevent imminent unlawful force.
Because of that distinction, the nature of the perceived threat and the response can become central issues in an assault case.
Does Michigan Require You to Retreat?
Not necessarily.
Michigan's Self-Defense Act provides circumstances in which a person has no duty to retreat before using force. Michigan's model jury instructions explain that this protection can apply when the person is not committing a crime, has a legal right to be where they are, and meets the applicable requirements concerning the necessity of force.
However, retreat rules can become more complicated depending on the facts, including whether the accused was engaged in criminal activity or participated in starting the confrontation.
For that reason, the phrase "Michigan is a stand-your-ground state" should not be treated as meaning that force is automatically justified whenever someone feels threatened.
What if You Started the Confrontation?
Being involved in starting an argument does not necessarily answer the entire self-defense question, but it can significantly affect the analysis.
Michigan courts recognize distinctions involving initial aggressors and willing participants in confrontations. The applicable self-defense rules can depend on how the encounter began, whether circumstances changed, whether the other person escalated the confrontation, and whether retreat was safely available when legally required.
This is one reason the entire sequence of events should be examined rather than focusing solely on the moment physical force was used.
What Evidence Can Support a Self-Defense Claim?
Self-defense cases often depend heavily on evidence showing what happened before and during the confrontation.
Potentially important evidence may include:
- Surveillance footage
- Cellphone videos
- Body-camera footage
- Photographs
- Injuries to the accused
- Medical records
- Witness statements
- 911 recordings
- Text messages
- Social media messages
- Prior threats relevant to the incident
- Physical evidence from the scene
Preserving this information as early as possible can be important because videos may be overwritten, messages may disappear, and witnesses' memories can become less precise over time.
What if Both People Were Fighting?
Cases involving a mutual physical confrontation can be more complicated.
The fact that both people used force does not necessarily resolve whether one person's actions were legally justified. A court may need to consider who initiated the physical confrontation, whether someone escalated the level of force, whether the accused reasonably believed further force was imminent, and whether the response was justified under the circumstances.
Michigan's jury instructions specifically address situations in which someone who initially engaged in certain conduct may still have self-defense rights if the other person escalates the confrontation to deadly force.
What Assault Charges Could You Face?
Michigan has several different assault offenses, and the potential charge depends on the circumstances.
For example, Michigan's general assault and assault-and-battery statute makes the basic offense a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days of imprisonment, a fine of up to $500, or both, when another punishment is not specifically provided. Different or enhanced penalties can apply depending on factors such as the alleged victim, prior convictions, injuries, weapons, and the particular assault offense charged.
More serious allegations can potentially result in felony charges and substantially greater consequences.
Who Has to Prove Self-Defense?
There is an important distinction between raising self-defense and ultimately disproving it.
Michigan courts explain that a defendant asserting an affirmative defense must first produce some evidence supporting the necessary elements of that defense. When sufficient evidence supports the defense and the defendant is entitled to the instruction, the prosecution bears the burden of disproving the defense beyond a reasonable doubt.
This makes identifying and preserving evidence supporting your version of the confrontation especially important.
What Should You Do After an Assault Arrest?
If you believe you acted in self-defense, avoid trying to prove your case through social media, arguments with the alleged victim, or conversations with potential witnesses.
Instead:
- Avoid publicly discussing the incident
- Follow all bond and no-contact conditions
- Preserve photographs, messages, videos, and other evidence
- Write down potential witnesses and relevant details for your attorney
- Attend every required court appearance
- Do not contact an alleged victim if the court has prohibited contact
An assault charge is an accusation, not a conviction. The circumstances and evidence still have to be evaluated.
Why Courtroom Experience Matters in an Assault Case
Self-defense cases can turn on detailed factual questions: who initiated the confrontation, what each person reasonably believed, whether the threat was imminent, and whether the force used was justified.
Those questions may ultimately have to be presented and argued in a courtroom.
Attorney Deborah Geraldine Bledsoe Ford served as a judge for 18 years and comes from a family of judges. She now brings that courtroom perspective to defending individuals facing assault and other serious criminal allegations throughout Michigan.
How Can Attorney Deborah Geraldine Bledsoe Ford Help?
If you have been charged with assault after a confrontation in which you believe you were protecting yourself or another person, the details matter.
Attorney Deborah Geraldine Bledsoe Ford represents clients throughout the state of Michigan facing assault, misdemeanor, felony, murder, and OWI charges. She can review the circumstances surrounding the confrontation, evaluate the prosecution's evidence, identify evidence relevant to self-defense, and help you understand your options as the case proceeds.
With 18 years of experience as a former judge, Attorney Ford brings extensive knowledge of the courtroom to the defense of serious criminal charges.
If you are facing an assault charge in Michigan, contact Attorney Deborah Geraldine Bledsoe Ford to discuss your rights and possible defenses.








